|
On Liberty and Utilitarianism
In the history of economic, political and philosophical thought few thinkers
have had a stronger influence than John Stuart Mill (1806-1873). He was
the last great exponent of the old classical school of economic liberalism,
but also, at the same time, an early forerunner of modern liberalism,
which seeks to make government a powerful instrument of regulation and
control. In the English-speaking world his though mesmerized and even
dominated the groves of Academe well into the 20th century. Although he
was a disciple of both Jeremy Bentham and David Ricardo, his writings
nearly always had a distinct character. Trying to be fair and judicious
in his discussion of any theory and doctrine, he always added numerous
modifications, extensions, qualifications, which often were so significant
that his theories became rather eclectic and even inconsistent.
John Stuart Mill was educated primarily by his eminent
father, James Mill. For thirty-five years John Stuart served the East
India Company. During this period, he contributed to various periodicals
and published two influential treatises: A System of Logic (1843)
and Principles of Political Economy (1848). Soon after the company's
dissolution in 1858, he published his famous On Liberty, in which
he discusses the notion of "Social Liberty:" the nature and
limits of the power which can be legitimately exercised by society over
the individual. In the long run, Mill believed that the state which dwarfs
its men, in order that they may be more docile instruments in its hands
even for beneficial purposes, will find that with small men no great thing
can be accomplished; and that the perfection of machinery to which it
has sacrificed everything will in the end avail it nothing, for want of
the vital power (found in free men) needed to run it smoothly, has been
vanished. On Liberty, which was followed by Utilitarianism
in 1863 and his Auguste Comte and Positivism in 1865. From
1865 to 1868, he served as an independent member of Parliament, after
which he retired, spending most of his time in Avignon, France, where
he died. His celebrated Autobiography appeared soon after his passing.
John Stuart Mill's utilitarianism is a form of consequentialism
advocating human action, which brings about the most good overall. Rightness
or wrongness is determined by its usefulness in bringing about the most
happiness of all individuals affected by it. Jeremy Bentham identified
good consequences with pleasure, which he sought to compare in terms of
intensity, duration, certainty, purity, and extent. John Stuart Mill introduced
to his utilitarianism calculus of pleasure a qualitative principle that
goes far beyondBentham's conception of utility. Although Mill always professed
to be a disciple of Bentham and claimed to espouse a utilitarian point
of view, and although utilitarianism significantly influenced his views,
he was no consistent defender of the system.
Mill distinguished two great classes of government intervention:
"Authoritative," in which legislators and regulators say, "do
this" or, "do that," and "non-authoritative"
or optional, in which they merely provide information and education. The
burden of proof rests primarily upon those individuals who advocate the
former; the latter is discretionary. Mill was substantially in accord
with Adam Smith although he allowed much more government interference
with the economic actions of the individual. "There are matters in
which the interference of the law is required," he wrote, "not
to overrule the judgements of individuals respecting their own interest,
but to give effect to that judgement; they being unable to give effect
to it except by concert, which concert again cannot be effectual unless
it receives validity and sanction from the law."
Mill was an ardent reformer, ever eager to change the
world for the better. He advocated proportional representation, emancipation
of women, the development of labor organizations, farm cooperatives, and
many other reforms. He pointed the way not only for some modifications
and improvements but also for serious impediments and injuries to the
private property order. His influence in economics, politics, and philosophy
continues to be strong throughout the English-speaking world.
|